Collection: Handmade Chunky Cookies

Experience the magic of our New York-style Chunky Chocolate Cookies, a Baked By The Bay signature!

Handcrafted with real ingredients, each cookie boasts a gooey, surprise-filled centre. Perfect as a thoughtful gift or indulgent treat, they’re freshly baked, beautifully packaged, and delivered Melbourne-wide and across Australia.

Our New York-style Chunky Chocolate Cookies are a true crowd-pleaser and a signature favourite on the Baked By The Bay dessert menu. Made from an original recipe, these cookies are chunky, rich, and crafted with real pantry-perfect ingredients—no preservatives, just wholesome goodness. Every cookie is handmade from scratch with care and love, ensuring a treat that’s as special as it is delicious.

What makes them unique? Each cookie features a filled centre, delivering a sweet surprise with every bite. Whether you’re gifting them for a birthday, saying thank you, or simply treating yourself, these cookies are guaranteed to delight. Choose to order them individually or include them in a dessert box alongside our decadent Loaded Chocolate Fudge Brownies for a mix of indulgent treats.

To make your gift extra special, we’ll beautifully gift-wrap the cookies for your chosen occasion. With our cookie delivery Melbourne-wide and Australia-wide shipping, you can send a little sweetness anywhere. Thanks to our heat-sealed packaging, your cookies stay fresh for weeks—although we’re sure they’ll be devoured long before that!

Pro tip: Warm your Chunky Cookies for about 20 seconds to enjoy their gooey centre and experience that just-baked perfection.

Order yours today and discover why these cookies are a Baked By The Bay favourite!